Bagel Shack

Classic Bagel, New Experience

Bagel Shack Opening This Holiday Season!

Call Us (201) 331-3237

bagel shack logo croped 1000
Message Us

395 NJ-17, Mahwah, NJ 07430

Classic Bagel, New Experience

Welcome to Bagel Shack, where every visit feels like home! 🥯 We stand out with our unique combination of quick and friendly 😊 service, a wide variety of ordering options, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re swinging by for a quick snack or settling in for a delightful feast, we’re here to make your experience memorable.

At Bagel Shack, we understand that everyone has their preferred way of ordering. That’s why we’ve got you covered, whether you’re paying with cash or card 💳, using our kiosks, drive-thru, phone, pick-up, DoorDash, or Uber Eats. Your convenience is our priority.

Our loyalty programs will keep you returning for more of our classic, hand-rolled, kettle-cooked, and daily baked bagels in various traditional styles and flavors. From the classic plain to the adventurous everything bagel, we’ve got something for everyone. Pair these with our artisan cream cheeses and top-quality deli meats for the ultimate sandwich 🥪 experience.

Take advantage of our daily specials, fresh-baked pastries 🥐, and house-crafted coffee ☕️ flavors.

Convenient parking 🅿️ accommodates even the most oversized vehicles, making us the perfect stop on your Route 17 journey. Bagel Shack is accessible from Route 17 south and northbound at Island Rd and MacArthur Boulevard in Mahwah, NJ.

Bagel Shack is proud to be the spot where regulars are greeted by name and newcomers quickly become friends. Join us for our community outdoor ☀️ events featuring food, drinks, coffee, music, and more. Everyone is welcome at Bagel Shack.

Bagel Shack’s Menu

hand-rolled Bagels

Bagels

Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Everything, Cinnamon Raisin, Whole Wheat, Egg, Pumpernickel, Rye, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Blueberry


*Baker’s Dozen = Buy 12 get 1 free

Mini Bagels

Bialy

roll

Hero

Croissant

bagel toppings

butter

butter and jelly

cream cheese

cream cheese and jelly

cream cheese and bacon

specialty cream cheese

peanut butter

peanut butter and jelly

specialty cream cheeses

freshly prepared on the premises

Vegetable, strawberry, green olive, jalapeño, horseradish, scallion, sundried tomato basil, bacon red onion, Nutella, walnut raisin, nova lox spread


*On a Bagel or Per Pound

cold cut sandwiches specials

italian

Ham, Genoa salami, ham cappy, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions, & oil vinegar
Roll, Hero or Wrap

Bonfire

Smoked Cracked Pepper Mill Turkey, pepper jack cheese, avocado, bacon, lettuce & chipotle mayo

Roll, Hero or Wrap

Millennial

Oven Gold Turkey, Swiss, avocado, bacon, lettuce, & Russian dressing

Roll, Hero or Wrap

bada bing

Prosciutto, soppressata, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomato, oil & vinegar

Roll, Hero or Wrap

southerner

Honey turkey, Virginia ham, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, & mayo

Roll, Hero or Wrap

american

Oven Gold Turkey, roast beef, American cheese, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo

Roll, Hero or Wrap

stable

Home cooked roast beef, cheddar, lettuce, tomato & horseradish sauce

Roll, Hero or Wrap

turkey club

Triple Decker sandwich of turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo on white toast with a side of coleslaw & pickle

Roll, Hero or Wrap

rancher

Oven Gold Turkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing

Roll, Hero or Wrap

new orleans

Cajun turkey, pepper jack, bacon, lettuce, tomato, chipotle mayo

Roll, Hero or Wrap

beehive

Honey turkey, Swiss, bacon, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard

Roll, Hero or Wrap

cold cuts

*Substitute rolls with:
Multi grain club, bagels, white, wheat, or rye bread croissants: extra

Deluxe Branded Ham

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Virginia Ham

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Extra Hot Cappy Brand Ham

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Ovengold Turkey

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Cracked Pepper Mill Tukey

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Maple Honey Turkey

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Cajun Turkey

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

EverRoast Chicken

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Blazing Buffalo Chicken

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Home Cooked Roast Beef

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Pastrami

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Corned Beef

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Genoa Salami

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Sandwich Style Pepperoni

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

cold cuts continued

Pork & Beef Bologna

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Liverwurst

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

American

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Gold Label Imported Swiss

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Picante Sharp Provolone

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Sharp Cheddar

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Low Moisture Mozzarella

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Muenster

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Monterrey Jack with Jalapeño

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Chipotle Gouda

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Lacey Swiss

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Asiago

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Sweet Soppressata Grande

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

Prosciutto di Parma

Roll, Hero, Wrap, Per lb

hot drinks

coffee

Regular or decaf
12 oz. Small
16 oz. Medium
20 oz. Large

Flavored coffee

12 oz. Small
16 oz. Medium
20 oz. Large

tea

Regular or decaf
12 oz. Small
16 oz. Medium
20 oz. Large

herbal tea

12 oz. Small
16 oz. Medium
20 oz. Large

hot chocolate

12 oz. Small
16 oz. Medium
20 oz. Large

box coffee

Serves 10. Includes cups, milk, cream, sugar, sweeteners & stirrers

urn coffee

Serves 50. Includes cups, milk, cream, sugar, sweeteners & stirrers

cold drinks

coffee

Regular or decaf
24 oz. Small
32 oz. Large

Flavored coffee

24 oz. Small
32 oz. Large

iced tea

24 oz. Small
32 oz. Large

latte

24 oz. Small
32 oz. Large

flavored latte

Hazelnut, vanilla, pumpkin spice, caramel
24 oz. Small
32 oz. Large

cafe mocha

24 oz. Small
32 oz. Large